Finding Aid to the Thomas Sully Papers, 1826-1872

Col. 164


© Winterthur Museum, Garden, and Library  
Winterthur, DE 19735  

Winterthur Logo
Table of contents

Background note:
Thomas Sully was a portrait, miniature, and figure painter. He was born on June 19, 1783, in Horncastle, Lincolnshire, England, the fourth child of Matthew and Sarah Chester, who were both actors. In 1792, the family emigrated to the United States and settled in Charleston, South Carolina. Sully began his professional life in the office of an insurance broker. Although he and his employer soon realized his aptitude was for artistic endeavors, the time spent in the business world served Sully well as he was astute in his later financial affairs. Next, he was placed under the tutelage of Jean Belzons, his brother-in-law, and in September 1799 he joined an older brother, Lawrence Sully, a miniature and device painter, in Richmond, Virginia. In 1801, he began his independent career in Norfolk, Va. Sully married his sister-in-law in 1805, after the death of his brother, and they moved to New York City. Two years later he moved on to Hartford, Connecticut, and Boston, Massachusetts, but in 1808 settled permanently in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

From 1809 to 1810, Sully was in England receiving art instruction from Benjamin West and Sir Thomas Lawrence. Upon his return and the subsequent deaths of Charles Willson Peale and Gilbert Stuart, he became the leading portrait painter in the United States. He knew most, if not all, the leading artists of the day, both in America and abroad. In 1837, the Society of Sons of St. George commissioned Sully to paint a portrait of Queen Victoria. He traveled to England with his daughter, Blanche, and returned in 1838, having done many portraits. After returning to Philadelphia, Sully averaged 35 to 40 portraits a year for the remainder of his life and made occasional professional visits to Baltimore, Boston, Washington, D.C., Charleston, Providence, and Richmond. Among his subjects were Thomas Jefferson, Lafayette, Charles Carroll of Carrollton, Andrew Jackson, King Charles, Benjamin Rush, and Washington Irving. Sully died in Philadelphia on November 5, 1872. Of his nine children, six survived infancy and all were either amateur or professional artists, while one of his step-daughters married the portrait painter, John Neagle.

Scope and content
This is an artificial collection made up of Sully manuscripts acquired over a period of time. The highlights of it are the two volumes of “Letters from England” (84×130) and a volume that Sully entitled “Memoirs of the Professional Life of Thomas Sully Dedicated to his Brother Artists, Philadelphia, November 1851” (91×19).

The letters in the two volumes of “Letters from England” were written by Sully and his daughter, Blanche, during a trip to England in 1837 and 1838. The memoirs were begun in 1851. The letters from England discuss the Sullys' social activities in London, while Sully's memoirs are more concerned with technical details of painting. Together, these items offer Sully's comments on the world of art and his fellow artists.

Additional material includes an inventory of Sully's possessions at his death and a codicil to his will, a certificate entitling Sully to a share in the property of the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts (1831), an admission ticket to a Royal Academy event, a letter to Robert P. Smith, dated November 8, 1834, declining a dinner invitation and including a toast for the dinner, two checks from the Bank of the United States, a letter to an engraver about copying a painting, a note about recanvassing and repainting an early Sully portrait (1854), a letter to M. Carey discussing his brother's ability as an artist with mentions of Washington Allston, and a receipt for a frame made by M. Williamson.

A card file that indexes names of people, places, and objects in the Sully letter books has been created; however, there is a separate file for each volume. A summary of the contents of each of the 28 letters is also available.

A summary of contents has also been compiled for Sullys' memoirs. A portion of the memoirs was published as Hints to Young Painters and Processes of Portrait Painting after Sully's death. A copy is in the Rare Book Room (RBR ND1262 S95).


Administrative information

Restrictions
None

Copyright restrictions may apply

Provenance
Acquired from various sources.


Additional descriptive information

Note
OVERVIEW OF THE COLLECTION Repository code: DeWint File name: coll64.xml Abstract: Thomas Sully was a portrait, miniature, and figure painter. The highlights of the collection are copies of his letters written while in England 1837-1838, and his memoirs. Also included are an inventory of his possessions at his death, some correspondence, checks, and other items. Extent: 0.4 linear feet Date range: 1826-1872 Related materials: Language: English Winterthur Museum, Garden, and Library Joseph Downs Collection of Manuscripts and Printed Ephemera Winterthur, DE 19732 (302) 888-4853 Thomas Sully Papers Col. 164 Creator: Thomas Sully, 1783-1872 Title: Papers Dates: 1826-1872 Call No.: Col. 164 Acc. No.: [varoius - see detailed description] Quantity: 1 box Location: 17 A 4


Added entries

Subjects
  • Allston, Washington, 1779-1843.
  • Art criticism.
  • Artists - Social life and customs.
  • Artists' materials.
  • Artists' tools.
  • Inheritance and succession.
  • Inventories of decedents' estates.
  • Painting, Modern - 19th century - History.
  • Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts.
  • Portrait painting - 19th century.
  • Portrait painting, American.
  • Sully family.

    Genre terms
  • Checks.
  • Estate records.
  • Inventories.
  • Letters.
  • Receipts.

    Functions and occupations
  • Artists.
  • Painters.

    Contact information

    Winterthur Museum, Garden, and Library
    [http://www.winterthur.org]
    Winterthur, DE 19735

     


    Collection inventory


    56 × 13.6.1.  Inventory and appraisal of Sully's possessions at his death, 1872. Also includes a list of bequests to various people of art objects and related tools such as brushes, palettes, etc. His daughters received money.
    1872.
    Folder 1

    56 × 13.6.2a-b.  Codicils to will of Thomas Sully, 1865-1866.
    1865-1866.


    65 × 76.  Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts certificate made out to Sully, 1831, entitling him to one share of property in the institution.
    1831,
    Folder 2


    65 × 98.  Sully's admission ticket to the Royal Academy.
    Folder 3


    68 × 48.  Two checks from the Bank of the United States, one made out to Sully, 1826, and the other endorsed by Sully, 1830.
    1826,


    68 × 17.4.  Sully sends his regrets to Richard P. Smith on November 8, 1834, for not being able to accept a dinner invitation. He includes a toast.
    Folder 4


    68×152.  Letter to Mr. Hart from Sully, Philadelphia, November 17, 1863, in regards to a set of letters. (#3095)
    November 17, 1863,


    73 × 190.  Letter regarding a painting that an unidentified engraver [John Sartain, perhaps] would like to copy, 1847. Sully suggests a painting of a child asleep with a rosebud.
    1847.


    74 × 421.  Letter from Sully to M. Carey, 1834, discussing Carey's brother as an artist. He also mentions Washington Allston.
    1834,


    78 × 5.  Letter from Sully to “My dear Koecker” on recanvassing and repairing a portrait, 1854.
    1854.


    79 × 299.  Receipt for a frame, signed by Sully.


    Ph1343.  Note to General Nicholas Ridgely about a portrait which Mr. Peale is to varnish and the frame for the portrait, August 5, 1818;
    August 5, 1818;

    on same sheet: receipt signed by Rembrandt Peale, acknowledging Ridgely's payment, October 1, 1818, (photograph of an original document at Hampton House, Towson, Maryland


    69×46.  Group of letters to John Sartain, Philadelphia engraver, from Sully:
    Folder 5

    .1.  May 28, 1844. concerns Mr. Wilcock's agreement of terms for and engraving of the “Hoqua;” asks for criticism of new painting.
    May 28, 1844.

    .2.  March 16, 1858. Sully declines an invitation to be on a committee representing the Academy of Fine Arts at a convention in Washington.
    March 16, 1858.

    .3.  March 19, 1865. Requests West portrait to varnish while the Academy of Fine Arts is closed to mount an exhibit.
    March 19, 1865.

    .4.  January 10, 1866. Introduces Mr. Price and requests Sartain to show Price an engraving he did of Sully's painting “Rose-bud.”
    January 10, 1866.

    .5.  October 28, 1871. Asks Sartain if he has engraved Trumbull's portrait of Washington.
    October 28, 1871.

    .6.  November 28, n.y. Sully thanks Sartain for loan of picture.
    November 28, n.y.

    .7.  n.d. Letter to Mr. and Miss Sartain from Sully's daughter, Blanche, requesting they accept a bust of Venus D'Arles owned by her father.
    n.d.


    84 × 130.1 -.2..  Two volumes of manuscripts containing the text of letters Sully and Blanche wrote to family in Philadelphia during their stay in London, 1837-1838, while Sully painted the portrait of Queen Victoria. The two volumes include copies of fourteen letters from each of the two Sullys. The letterbooks were compiled by Jane Sully, another of Thomas Sully's daughters; the original letters have apparently been lost. Each letter is lengthy and full of detail about where the Sullys lived in London; their encounters with the British art establishment of the 1830s and with other American artists; dining with members of the Audubon family; a trip to France; portrait commissions, including the one negotiated with Queen Victoria; viewing art exhibitions; the experiences of a young woman abroad for the first time; and domestic considerations relating to clothing and the household routine. Also included is a plan of the rooms of the house on Great Marlborough St., London, where Sully and Blanche stayed in 1838. (A document summarizing the letters is available at this repository, as is an index to the names mentioned in the letters.)
    1837-1838,
    Folders 6 and 7


    88×215.7,.12,.13,.25.  Four small engravings of Sully paintings by various engravers, all depicting children.
    Folder 8


    [unnumbered].  Photocopy of typescript entitled “Thomas Sully's Hints for Pictures,” noted as having been “copied August-September 1921, from the original manuscript in the possession of Mrs. M.H. Sully, 102 Cambridge Place, Brooklyn, New York City.” There is no indication as to who did the transcription; it may have been T. Lawrence.
    Folder 9


    91 × 19.  “Memoirs of the Professional Life of Thomas Sully...”
    Folder 10

    Thomas Sully's memoirs cover two areas of his professional life: the techniques of his artistry and his recollections of some of the painters that he knew. In the preface to this manuscript, Sully writes that through his work as an artist, he collected hints and gained experiences that he wanted to pass on to other painters. Among the painting techniques that Sully wrote about were the most important facial features that a portrait needed to highlight, how to paint backgrounds, the usefulness of sketching and modeling in clay for the painter, and how to most effectively arrange a palette. Sully reconstructs a palette that he considered “the best I have tried” and another that he customarily used for a third portrait sitting. Reflecting his admiration for Gilbert Stuart, Sully records two of his palettes, one of which was designed specifically for painting flesh. Sully also addresses different ways in which varnishes were used and provides formulae for paints and varnishes. He even includes a color chart to show how primary colors were mixed to produce other colors. Sully used small drawings to augment his thoughts. One of his illustrations depicts John Trumbull's small exhibition room on Barclay St., New York City, while another relates to the use of light in portrait painting.

    Sully comments on painters of his and other generations and critiques their work. Artists including Gilbert Stuart, Thomas Gainsborough, Henry Fuseli, Charles Willson Peale, Benjamin West, Joshua Reynolds, Washington Allston, Thomas Lawrence, C.R. Leslie, and J.M.W. Turner all come under Sully's scrutiny. Of West, he notes: “I need not say how much I reaped from the services of this good man; he treated me as if I had been his son.” Sully also remarks on a study group in which he took part while in London and his activities with other artists everywhere.

    In 1873, a short edited version of these memoirs, Hints to Young Painters and the Process of Portrait Painting, was printed under Sully's name as a posthumous publication. F.T.S. Darley, Sully's grandson, was the editor. The manuscript contains Darley's penciled-in editorial revisions. After Thomas Sully's death, this manuscript was probably passed on to his daughter, Jane Darley. F.T.S. Darley had earlier given it to Thomas Nash of New York, as evidenced by a title page inscription: “The property of Thomas Nash, New York, given him by F.T.S. Darley.” In 1991, it was “discovered” in a safe deposit box maintained by a descendent of Thomas Sully, and subsequently sold at auction. A typed summary of the memoir is available at this repository.

    The memoir is also available on microfilm, Mic. 2930.


    Related Thomas Sully items in other collections:

    57 × 18..  Mrs. Joseph Carson Collection (Col. 66) features manuscripts from artists. Sully is represented with items.208, .224, .227, .229, .209, .210, and.259.

    62 × 33..  Norris family scrapbook (Fol. 241), in which Sully is mentioned on pages 150, 153, and 156.

    64 × 8.2..  John Stevens Cogdell discusses Sully at some length (Col. 252).

    67 × 112.3..  Sully mentioned in a printed letter (Col. 361, Miscellaneous Letters).

    67 × 121..  Scrapbook of portraits at the Union League Club, New York City, compiled by T. B. Clarke shows some of Sully's works: pages 12, 24, 69, 71. (Col. 315)

    69 × 9..  Mentioned in a pamphlet of the proceedings of the National Convention of Artists, 1858, pages 4 and 15. (Rare Books N21 W31)
    1858,

    69 × 46.1-7..  A letter to John Sartain from Sully and daughter, Blanche, 1840s, in the John Sartain Papers (Col. 398).
    1840s,

    72 × 123..  Correspondence about paintings in the form of several letters to Miss Eunice Chambers (Col. 451).

    72×359.  Lawrence Park Papers (Col. 96) discusses Sully in work on colonial art.

    81 × 453..  Mentioned in the Mantle Fielding Papers (Col. 207), boxes 1 and 2.

    87 × 65..  Details of Sully's friendship with fellow artist, Jonathan Mason, Jr., in Mason's Recollections (Doc. 30).

    Ph1305..  Broadside announcing a meeting of the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, 1812, with Sully mentioned.
    1812,

    M101.  Charles N. Bancker papers number .27: Sully wants to paint a portrait in the Bancker collection.

    Mic. 791 and reels following..  Pennsylvania Academy papers.

    Mic.892-894..  Mentioned in artists in New Orleans, compiled by the WPA.

    Mic. 913.  Mentioned in a dissertation on John Neagle, 1959.
    1959.